Denial codes · Denial code

PR-119 and CO-119 denial code: the benefit maximum was reached

The short answerCARC 119 means the patient's benefit maximum for the period has been reached, so the payer did not pay this nutrition visit. With PR-119 the patient is responsible under the plan; with CO-119 you are. For Medicare MNT, more hours require a new physician referral for a change in condition (billed with G0270/G0271); for commercial plans, check the count and whether earlier visits were misapplied.
Official descriptionBenefit maximum for this time period or occurrence has been reached.
PR-119Patient responsible: bill per your financial policy
CO-119Provider responsible: write off unless your contract says otherwise
Medicare MNT3 hours the first year, 2 hours each year after; more with a new referral
Common remark codesN362 (units over maximum), N640 (frequency exceeded), N130
Fix routeVerify the count; appeal only if visits were miscounted

PR-119 and CO-119 mean the plan's benefit maximum for the period was reached, so the payer did not pay this visit. With PR-119 the patient is responsible; with CO-119 you are.

A 119 denial usually lands on a follow-up the patient was counting on, weeks after the visit. Everything about the claim can be right, the same shape as the ones that paid before, and it still comes back unpaid, because the plan's counter hit zero. The fix is less about the claim and more about knowing the count before you book.

What 119 means and why the group code matters

The X12 CARC list defines code 119 as:

"Benefit maximum for this time period or occurrence has been reached."

The group code decides who pays. With PR-119 the plan says the patient is responsible, and you bill the patient under your financial policy. With CO-119 the provider is responsible. In network that usually means a write-off, because the contract does not let you bill the member for amounts the payer assigns to you.

119 often travels with a remark code. We have seen a commercial plan return PR-119 with N362 ("The number of Days or Units of Service exceeds our acceptable maximum.") on a 97803 follow-up whose structure was identical to earlier paid claims. Nothing was wrong with the claim; the patient's annual nutrition allowance was used up. N640 ("Exceeds number/frequency approved/allowed within time period.") is another common partner.

How payers cap nutrition therapy

Caps come in several shapes, and the shape changes how fast a patient burns through them:

Cap type How it counts What to watch
Visits per plan year Each date of service is one visit, regardless of length Some plans count 97802 and 97803 together
Units per year Each 15-minute unit counts A 60-minute visit uses four units at once
Hours per year Medicare MNT: 3 hours the first year, 2 hours each year after Initial assessments eat the hours fastest
Dollar maximum Rare for nutrition, seen in some plans Allowed amounts, not your charges, count
Shared caps The same counter as other nutrition providers, or a plan wellness program Visits with another RD earlier in the year count

Medicare. The MNT benefit is three hours in the first year and two hours in each later year (NCD 180.1). The treating physician can order additional hours when there is a change in medical condition, diagnosis or treatment regimen (42 CFR 410.132); those are billed with G0270 (individual) or G0271 (group) rather than 97803. See our G0270 and G0271 guide. Also remember the plan year is not always the calendar year: Medicare's first MNT episode can be a 12-month period when coordinated with diabetes self-management training.

Commercial plans set their own limits, and many do not publish them in their medical policies. The only reliable source is the member's benefits, confirmed on a call and written down with the representative's name and reference number.

How to fix a 119 denial

  1. Confirm the count. Call the payer and ask how many visits or units were applied this plan year, on which dates and by which providers. Misapplied visits happen: a denied or voided claim can still count, and another provider's visit can be applied to the wrong benefit.
  2. If the count is wrong, ask the payer to reprocess, or appeal with your own visit log and the benefit quote you received before the visit (with its reference number). Our post on when a payer quoted the wrong benefits covers that appeal.
  3. If the count is right, there is nothing to fix on the claim:
    • PR-119: bill the patient per your financial policy.
    • CO-119: write it off, unless your contract allows a signed waiver collected before the visit.
    • Medicare: if the patient's condition, diagnosis or treatment has changed, ask the physician for a referral for additional hours. For services you expect Medicare to deny as over the limit, review the ABN rules before the next visit, not after.
  4. Do not switch codes to dodge the cap. Billing 99401-99404 or S9470 instead of 97803 is only legitimate if the documented service meets that code's definition and the plan covers it for dietitians. Otherwise it is misbilling.

Initial visits use up a cap faster than follow-ups because they run longer. 97802 vs 97803 explains when each code applies, and the CPT code finder shows the units a given visit length bills.

Duo Practice checks eligibility through your own Claim.MD account, matches each payment to its claim and explains every adjustment code on the remit. Try Duo Practice free

Know where each claim stands without logging into payer portals.

How to prevent CO-119 and PR-119

Ask four cap questions on every benefits check. Is there a limit on nutrition visits, units or hours? Per what period, calendar or plan year? How many are used? Are they shared with other providers or programs?

Don't rely on the 271 alone. Electronic eligibility checks confirm coverage but often leave out nutrition visit counts; see electronic eligibility checks (270/271).

Keep your own counter for each patient and benefit period, and tell the patient before the last covered visit. Verify again at plan renewal, because counters reset and plan rules change with them. Then plan the care around the cap: front-load the assessment and the follow-ups that matter most, and agree a clear self-pay rate in writing before any visit beyond the limit.

For the full script, see our benefits verification call script. For every other nutrition denial code, go to the denial code lookup.

Another code on the same remittance? Paste the whole line into the free claim denial checker to see what each code means and who owes the amount.

The activity list in Duo Practice: each visit's date, length, client, payment method and the amount paid.
Payments in Duo Practice (test data). Each visit shows how it was billed and what came back, so a claim that paid nothing stands out.

Sources

  1. X12: Claim Adjustment Reason Codes (CARC 119)
  2. X12: Remittance Advice Remark Codes (N362, N640, N130)
  3. CMS: NCD 180.1 Medical Nutrition Therapy (hours per year)
  4. eCFR via Cornell LII: 42 CFR 410.132, MNT limitations on coverage

Sources checked . Payer rules change; verify the member's benefits.

Frequently asked questions

How many nutrition visits does Medicare cover?

Medicare counts hours, not visits: three hours of MNT in the first year and two hours in each later year. The physician can order more hours for a change in diagnosis, medical condition or treatment regimen.

Can I switch to a different CPT code when the MNT visits run out?

Only if the service you actually provided and documented meets that other code's definition and the plan covers it for your provider type. Changing codes just to get around a cap is misbilling.

Will an eligibility check show how many nutrition visits are left?

Often not. A 270/271 eligibility response confirms coverage but frequently does not report remaining nutrition visits. Ask on the benefits call how many visits or units were used this plan year, including by other providers.

Part of Denials, ERAs & appeals.