Denial codes · Denial code

CO-242 on a nutrition claim: the plan only pays its network providers

The short answerCO-242 means the plan did not pay because you're not in the network it requires for this member (or the member's primary care provider's network). On nutrition claims it usually means an HMO or EPO plan with no out-of-network benefit, a plan product your contract doesn't include, or a plan that routes care through the PCP. Check your network status for that exact product first: if you're in network, ask for reprocessing; if not, the answer is an exception or agreement before future visits, not a corrected claim.
Official descriptionServices not provided by network/primary care providers.
HistoryReplaced deactivated CARC 38 in 2012
Group codeUsually CO; sometimes PR when the plan assigns it to the member
Typical plansHMO and EPO products without out-of-network benefits
First checkAre you in network for this member's specific product, on this date?
Fix routeReprocessing if you are in network; exception or agreement going forward if not

CO-242 tells you the plan has a closed door and you were outside it. The patient has coverage, and the service may well be covered, but only when a provider in the plan's network (or the patient's primary care provider's network) delivers it. For dietitians, it usually shows up the first time you see a patient on a product you did not know you were not contracted for.

What CO-242 means (official X12 wording)

The X12 Claim Adjustment Reason Code list defines CARC 242 as:

"Services not provided by network/primary care providers."

X12 notes it replaced the deactivated code 38. Remark codes vary; N52 ("Patient not enrolled in the billing provider's managed care plan on the date of service.") and N130 ("Consult plan benefit documents/guidelines for information about restrictions for this service.") are two you may see alongside it.

Why network status is product by product

A common trap: "I'm in network with Carrier X." Carriers sell many products, and a provider contract usually lists which ones it covers. HealthCare.gov's plan types guide summarizes the main designs:

Plan type Out-of-network coverage What it means for your claim
HMO Generally none except emergencies; often requires a PCP and referrals Out-of-network visits come back unpaid, often CO-242
EPO Generally none except emergencies Same result, usually without the PCP requirement
PPO Yes, at higher member cost Out of network pays less but pays; CO-242 is unusual
POS Yes, usually with a PCP referral Depends on referral and network rules

The HMO and EPO glossary entries describe the "network only" rule. Marketplace plans, narrow-network employer plans and Medicaid managed care products are often HMO or EPO designs.

The usual causes on nutrition claims

1. You're contracted for the PPO but the patient has the HMO or EPO

The card has the carrier's logo you know, so the visit got booked. The product on the card is one your contract excludes. This is the single most common cause.

2. A Marketplace or narrow-network product

Marketplace plans and some employer plans use smaller networks than the carrier's commercial PPO. Being in the big network doesn't put you in the small one.

3. A PCP-directed plan

Some HMOs and medical-group-based plans pay specialists and allied providers only within the PCP's contracted group or with the PCP's referral on file. A dietitian outside that group, or without the referral, gets CO-242.

4. Medicaid managed care

A patient can move between Medicaid managed care plans, and your contract with one doesn't carry over to another. Verify the plan assignment for the date of service.

5. The payer didn't recognize your contract

The claim was billed under an NPI, tax ID or service location that doesn't match your contract record (for example, a new group NPI or a new office address not yet added). The payer processes you as out of network. This one is fixable on the claim. If you really are out of network for the plan, a corrected claim changes nothing.

A BlueCard note

With out-of-state Blue members, the claim goes to your local Blue plan, and your network status depends on the member's product and your local contract. Read BlueCard for out-of-state Blue members before assuming.

How to fix a CO-242

  1. Check your participation for this exact plan and date. Call provider services or check the payer's provider directory and portal. Ask: "Am I participating for the [product name] product on [date]?"
  2. If you're in network, and the payer made an error, ask for reprocessing with a call reference; if refused, file a reconsideration or appeal with your contract or participation letter.
  3. If your provider data was wrong (NPI, tax ID, location), fix it with the payer and send a corrected claim (frequency code 7 with the original claim number).
  4. If the plan needed a PCP referral and the patient has one, submit it as the plan requires and ask for reprocessing; referral rules differ by plan.
  5. If you're truly out of network, the claim won't be paid as billed. For ongoing care, ask the plan about a network gap exception or a single-case agreement before the next visit. Some plans offer them when no in-network dietitian can reasonably provide the service; none are guaranteed.
  6. Patient balance: follow your contracts, state rules and the patient's signed financial policy. If you told the patient you were in network, fix that expectation directly before any statement goes out.

Duo Practice runs eligibility checks through your Claim.MD account, so the plan and product on file show up before the first visit. Try Duo Practice free

Know the plan before the patient is on your calendar.

How to prevent CO-242

Keep a list of the products each contract covers, not just the carriers, and get it in writing when you credential.

Verify the plan type at booking. The product name, plan type (HMO, EPO, PPO) and group number are on the card and in the eligibility response. Our insurance verification call script includes "Is this provider in network for this member's plan?" For every HMO member, ask about PCP and referral rules too.

For out-of-network patients, offer a clear self-pay path agreed before the visit. See cash pay vs insurance for how practices structure it. And when you move or change your NPI or tax ID, update the payer before you bill from the new setup.

If the payer says you, specifically, were not yet credentialed on that date, the code is usually CO-B7 instead. For every other code, see the denial code lookup.

Another code on the same remittance? Paste the whole line into the free claim denial checker to see what each code means and who owes the amount.

The activity list in Duo Practice: each visit's date, length, client, payment method and the amount paid.
Payments in Duo Practice (test data). Each visit shows how it was billed and what came back, so a claim that paid nothing stands out.

Sources

  1. X12: Claim Adjustment Reason Codes (CARC 242, replaces 38)
  2. X12: Remittance Advice Remark Codes (N52, N130)
  3. HealthCare.gov: Health Maintenance Organization (HMO)
  4. HealthCare.gov: Exclusive Provider Organization (EPO) plan
  5. HealthCare.gov: Health insurance plan and network types

Sources checked . Payer rules change; verify the member's benefits.

Frequently asked questions

I am in network with this insurer. Why CO-242?

Insurers sell many products (PPO, HMO, EPO, narrow-network and Marketplace plans), and a contract often covers only some of them. You can be in network for the carrier's PPO and out of network for its HMO or a Marketplace product. Check your participation for the specific plan on the member's card.

Can I bill the patient for a CO-242?

With a CO group code, the payer is not assigning it to the patient. If you are in network for the plan, you generally cannot bill the member. If you have no contract at all, whether you can bill depends on state law, any network agreement you are part of, and what the patient agreed to in writing before the visit.

What is a network gap exception?

Some plans will authorize an out-of-network provider at in-network benefit levels when the network has no adequate provider for the service, for example no in-network dietitian nearby for a specific condition. It usually has to be requested before the visit. Ask the plan whether it offers one and how to request it.

Part of Denials, ERAs & appeals.