Denial codes · Denial code

CO-4 on telehealth nutrition claims: fix the modifier

The short answerCO-4 means the payer found the modifier on the line inconsistent with the procedure code. On nutrition claims it almost always involves telehealth: modifier 95, GT or 93 that the payer does not accept for 97802/97803, or a modifier that conflicts with POS 02 or 10. Look up that payer's telehealth rules, fix the modifier and POS together, and send a corrected claim.
Official descriptionThe procedure code is inconsistent with the modifier used.
Group codeCO (provider liable): do not bill the patient
Common remark codesN822 (missing modifier), N823 (invalid modifier), N519 (invalid combination)
Telehealth POS02 other than home, 10 in the patient's home
Medicare professional claimsIdentify telehealth with POS 02/10 (CMS MLN901705, Dec 2025)
Fix routeCorrected claim (frequency 7) with the payer's modifier and POS

CO-4 is a mismatch between the procedure code and its modifier. On nutrition claims the modifier is almost always the telehealth one, so in a mostly virtual practice this is the denial that follows any change in a payer's telehealth rules.

What CO-4 means

Code 4 in the X12 CARC list means:

"The procedure code is inconsistent with the modifier used."

The modifier may be wrong, missing, or not allowed on that code at that payer. The remark code tells you which. From the X12 remark code list:

The CO group code means you are liable. Do not bill the patient for a CO-4.

Telehealth modifier and POS combinations

There is no single right answer for 97802/97803 via telehealth. What each payer wants depends on its telehealth policy, and policies change. Here are the building blocks:

Element Meaning Notes
POS 02 "Telehealth Provided Other than in Patient's Home" Patient at a clinic, workplace or other non-home site
POS 10 "Telehealth Provided in Patient's Home" Most virtual MNT visits
Modifier 95 Synchronous telemedicine via real-time audio and video Required by many commercial payers
Modifier GT Via interactive audio and video telecommunication systems Older; some payers still accept it, others reject it
Modifier 93 Synchronous telemedicine via telephone or other real-time audio-only Only where the payer covers audio-only

Medicare

The current CMS telehealth booklet (MLN901705, December 2025) tells professionals to report telehealth with POS 02 or POS 10 as of January 1, 2024. In that booklet, modifier 95 is described for outpatient therapy services billed on institutional claims, and GT for institutional claims from critical access hospitals under method II. Some Medicare contractors publish their own modifier instructions for professional claims, so confirm with yours before changing a claim. MNT codes 97802, 97803 and G0270 are on Medicare's telehealth services list; where the patient can be (home or not) is a separate rule, covered in our Medicare telehealth for MNT guide.

Commercial and Medicaid plans

Many commercial payers want modifier 95 plus POS 02 or 10; some want POS 10 with no modifier; a few still require GT or ask for the in-person POS (11) plus 95. Medicaid programs and their managed care plans set their own rules by state. Keep a one-line entry per payer and update it when a CO-4 tells you something changed.

The usual causes on nutrition claims

  1. Wrong telehealth modifier for this payer: GT sent where the payer now requires 95, or 95 sent where the payer wants none.
  2. Modifier and POS disagree: 95 with POS 11 at a payer that expects POS 10, or POS 10 with no modifier at a payer that expects 95.
  3. Audio-only billed as video: a phone visit billed with 95, or billed with 93 at a payer that does not cover audio-only MNT.
  4. A modifier on a code the payer does not allow via telehealth. This is less common for 97802/97803, but check if you bill S9470 or group codes.
  5. A stale template: a practice-wide default modifier that no longer matches one payer's policy.

How to fix a CO-4

  1. Read the remark code and confirm which modifier the payer objected to.
  2. Look up the payer's current telehealth policy (provider manual or reimbursement policy) for 97802/97803: required modifier, allowed POS, and whether audio-only is covered.
  3. Check your note. Was the visit real-time audio and video, and where was the patient? The note should say both.
  4. Send a corrected claim: frequency code 7 in Item 22 of the CMS-1500 (or the 837P frequency code) with the original claim number, the corrected modifier in 24D and the POS in 24B.
  5. Update your payer rules so the next claim goes out right.

If the payer returned CO-16 with M77 instead, the problem is the POS itself; see CO-16.

Duo Practice drafts the modifier and POS from the session and, when a CO-4 comes back, explains it and resends a corrected claim. Try Duo Practice free

Duo Practice drafts the claim (CPT, units, modifier, POS) from the visit; you review it before it goes out.

How to prevent CO-4

For more on the full workflow, see telehealth billing for dietitians and CMS-1500 for dietitians. Check the denial code lookup for every other code.

Another code on the same remittance? Paste the whole line into the free claim denial checker to see what each code means and who owes the amount.

The activity list in Duo Practice: each visit's date, length, client, payment method and the amount paid.
Payments in Duo Practice (test data). Each visit shows how it was billed and what came back, so a claim that paid nothing stands out.

Sources

  1. X12: Claim Adjustment Reason Codes (CARC 4)
  2. X12: Remittance Advice Remark Codes (N822, N823, N519)
  3. CMS: Place of Service code set (POS 02 and 10)
  4. CMS MLN901705: Telehealth & Remote Patient Monitoring (December 2025)
  5. NUCC: 1500 Claim Form instructions (Items 24B and 24D)

Sources checked . Payer rules change; verify the member's benefits.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between POS 02 and POS 10?

POS 02 is telehealth provided other than in the patient's home. POS 10 is telehealth provided in the patient's home. Use the one that matches where the patient was during the visit.

Can I bill a phone-only nutrition visit as telehealth?

Only if the payer covers audio-only nutrition visits. Where it does, it usually wants modifier 93 or its own specific code. Many plans require real-time audio and video for MNT.

Do I appeal a CO-4?

Usually not. It is a coding mismatch, so a corrected claim with the right modifier and POS is faster. Appeal only if you used exactly what the payer's published policy requires.

Part of Denials, ERAs & appeals.