Audits & appeals

Payer requested your chart notes? What to send (and not)

Your insurance payer requested records. Here's how to tell a retrieval from an audit, what to send, what to skip, and how to respond on time.

You get a letter or portal message. It lists a few patients and dates, and asks you to send their records in about three weeks.

Most of what's written about these letters targets physician groups with a compliance officer, not a solo RD.

Not every records request is an audit. Many letters dietitians receive don't question your claims at all. Figure out which kind you have first. That one step tells you whether this is routine paperwork or a financial event.

Step zero: what kind of request is this?

Read the letter carefully. The type is almost always stated, though not always in plain language.

Type Who sends it What it's about Is your money at risk?
Risk adjustment / HEDIS retrieval Usually a vendor working for the plan, with names like Inovalon, Ciox, Datavant, or a similar retrieval company The plan's own quality scores and risk-adjustment data No
Pre-payment review The payer's claims or medical review department Whether a pending claim should be paid Payment is on hold
Post-payment review / audit The payer's audit unit Whether claims already paid were supported Yes: recoupment
SIU (special investigations unit) The payer's fraud unit Suspected fraud, waste, or abuse Yes, and more

Risk adjustment and HEDIS: the one that isn't an audit

If a third-party vendor asks for HEDIS, quality measures, Stars, risk adjustment, or annual reporting data and lists many members rather than specific claims, you're doing a data pull, not an audit. The plan is gathering data on its population's health or quality metrics. It is not deciding whether to pay you or take money back. There is no recoupment on the other end of it.

You still respond, and you still send only what's requested. But you can stop bracing for impact.

The medical-necessity reviews

The other three are about your claims.

A pre-payment review letter references specific pending claims and says payment is being held or the claim is suspended pending documentation. Cash flow stops until you respond.

A post-payment review references claims already paid, often from several months back, and usually cites the payer's right to review and recover overpayments. This is the one that ends in a recoupment demand if the notes don't hold up.

An SIU letter says special investigations, program integrity, or fraud on the letterhead or the signature line. The language is more formal, the request is often broader, and the deadline may be shorter. Call a health care attorney before you respond to this one. Do not treat an SIU letter as routine paperwork.

If you genuinely can't tell what you're holding, call the number on the letter and ask directly: "Is this a risk-adjustment retrieval or a medical-necessity review? Are any claims currently pending or under recovery?" Write down who you spoke to and when.

What to send

The rule does not change by request type: send exactly what was asked for, for exactly the dates requested, complete.

For a typical MNT records request, that means:

Complete means complete. A note that references an attached food log the reviewer never sees is a note with a hole in it. If your EHR splits the encounter across sections, export the whole encounter, not just the narrative field.

What not to send

This is where good intentions create problems.

Don't send extra dates of service. If they asked for three visits, send three. A reviewer looking at a fourth note you volunteered can flag it, and now you have four claims in play instead of three.

Don't send other patients' information. This sounds obvious and it happens constantly: a scanned batch with a stray page, a PDF export that pulled the wrong record, an unredacted schedule screenshot. Page-check every packet before it leaves. A disclosure of the wrong patient's PHI is its own separate problem, with its own separate consequences.

Don't send your entire chart when one note was requested. Volume doesn't read as thoroughness; it reads as an invitation to browse.

Don't send an explanation instead of a record. A long letter arguing why the visit was necessary cannot substitute for a note that shows it. Keep the cover letter short and factual.

And above all: never alter, rewrite, or backdate a note. Your EHR records when every entry was created and every edit was made. Reviewers can and do ask for the audit trail. A note that was clearly rewritten after the request date is no longer a documentation dispute you can lose money over. It is an allegation of falsified records, which is a different category of problem entirely, with licensure and criminal exposure attached. A thin note costs you one claim. A doctored note can cost you your practice.

If a note is genuinely incomplete, most systems allow a clearly labeled late entry or addendum that is timestamped as such and leaves the original intact. That is a legitimate correction. Overwriting history is not. Send both the original and the addendum, and say so in your cover letter.

Deadlines

The deadline is in the letter. It varies by payer, state, and request type. There's no universal number.

Put it on your calendar the day the letter arrives, not the day you get around to it. A missed deadline on a medical-necessity review is usually treated as no documentation at all: perfect notes you didn't send on time don't count.

Extensions are commonly granted if you ask in writing before the deadline. Send the request ID, your reason, and the date you need. Late requests are rarely approved.

Your step-by-step response

  1. Identify the type. Retrieval, pre-payment, post-payment, or SIU. Everything else follows from this.
  2. Calendar the deadline and set a reminder a week out.
  3. Verify the requester. If a vendor is asking, confirm they're acting for a plan your patient is actually enrolled with. Don't send records to an entity you can't verify.
  4. List exactly what's requested (patient, date of service, document type) as a checklist. Work the checklist.
  5. Pull the records as they exist. Export clean, legible PDFs with signatures visible. Don't edit anything.
  6. Page-check for stray PHI. Every page, every packet.
  7. Write a one-page cover letter. Request ID, list of what's enclosed by patient and date, your NPI and contact, and one factual line of context where it helps ("each note documents total session time supporting the units billed").
  8. Send with proof of delivery (certified mail or a portal submission receipt) and keep a complete copy of exactly what you sent.
  9. Diary the follow-up. If you hear nothing in 30 days on a payment-related review, call and ask for status in writing.

What auditors are actually checking

On a medical-necessity review, the reviewer is answering four questions.

First, does the documented time support the units billed? Time-based MNT codes need documented minutes. A note with no time statement cannot support 4 units, no matter how good the clinical content is.

Second, does the note show medical necessity for the diagnosis on the claim: why this patient needed MNT on this date? Our guide to charting for medical necessity covers what reviewers want to see.

Third, are the diagnosis codes consistent across note, referral, and claim? A mismatch here is one of the most common reasons a claim falls apart under review, and one of the most common causes of routine nutrition claim denials too.

Fourth, is the note signed and dated? To a reviewer, an unsigned note is not a note.

If a review ends badly, you still have options. The findings carry appeal rights, and the process looks a lot like appealing a denied nutrition claim, with more at stake. Payer-specific expectations differ, and documentation requirements by payer is worth reading before you're the one holding the letter.

Once more: this is general information, not legal advice. If a request escalates to alleged fraud, comes from an SIU, or carries a large recoupment demand, get a health care attorney involved before you respond.

Duo Practice drafts the note and the claim from the same recorded session: units from the session time, the same ICD-10 codes on both. When a records request shows up months later, the note and the claim already line up. Duo Practice doesn't represent you in an audit and doesn't give legal advice.

A signed chart in Duo Practice with history, lifestyle, diet recall, medications and PES statement sections.
A signed chart in Duo Practice (test patient): history, lifestyle, diet recall, medications and the PES statement, drafted from the recorded session for you to review. Try Duo Practice free

Frequently asked questions

Do I need patient authorization to send records to an insurance company?

Generally no, when the request is tied to payment or health care operations for a patient that plan covers. HIPAA permits disclosures for treatment, payment, and operations without separate authorization. But you should still send only the minimum necessary to answer the request, verify the requester is who they claim to be, and confirm a business associate agreement or equivalent authority is in place when a third-party vendor is asking. If the request looks unusual or comes from an entity you cannot verify, slow down and confirm before you send anything.

Do I need a lawyer if a payer requests my records?

Not for a routine retrieval or a standard records request you can answer with clean documentation. You should talk to a health care attorney if the letter comes from a special investigations unit, alleges fraud or abuse, demands a large repayment, extrapolates an error rate across claims you did not submit for review, or threatens to terminate your contract or refer you elsewhere. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Part of MNT documentation. Start with How to write an MNT note that gets paid.